Legislative Competence over Education
SyllabusIssues relating to development and management of Social Sector/Services: education
Legislative competence over education is shared between Parliament and State Legislatures because education is primarily in the Concurrent List. Under Article 246, both can legislate on Concurrent List subjects, while Parliament has exclusive authority over specified Union List fields concerning national institutions and higher-education standards.
Allocation under the Seventh Schedule
The general field of education is distributed through Concurrent List Entry 25, subject to specific Union List entries.
- Concurrent List Entry 25 covers education, including technical education, medical education and universities, as well as vocational and technical training of labour.
- Union List Entries 63 and 64 cover specified universities and scientific or technical institutions declared by Parliament to be institutions of national importance.
- Union List Entry 65 covers Union agencies and institutions for professional or technical training, special studies, research and specified scientific assistance.
- Union List Entry 66 gives Parliament competence over coordination and determination of standards in higher education, research, and scientific and technical institutions.
- State List Entry 32 separately covers the incorporation, regulation and winding up of universities, subject to the constitutional distribution of powers.
How concurrent competence operates
States may legislate on the establishment, administration and regulation of education, but their competence remains subject to exclusive Union fields and valid parliamentary legislation.
- Under Article 254, a State law repugnant to a parliamentary law on a Concurrent List matter is ordinarily void to the extent of repugnancy.
- A repugnant State law may prevail within that State if it receives Presidential assent, but Parliament may subsequently override it.
- The Union's power under Entry 66 concerns national coordination and standards, while the broader operation of educational institutions falls within the shared field of Entry 25.
Historical shift
Education was originally placed in State List Entry 11. The Constitution (Forty-second Amendment) Act, 1976 omitted that entry and placed the general subject in Concurrent List Entry 25, creating shared legislative responsibility rather than exclusive Union control.
How UPSC asks this
May test the relevant entries, the Forty-second Amendment and rules of repugnancy.
Questions usually examine the balance between State administration, parliamentary legislation and Union control over higher-education standards.
Keep reading
The news behind topics like this, explained every morning
Every morning Gyaanam reads The Hindu, the Indian Express and PIB and picks what matters for UPSC. Each story is written up against the syllabus line it belongs to. Your first 15 days are free.