Reasonable Restrictions on Freedom of Speech

Article 19(1)(a) guarantees every citizen the freedom of speech and expression, but this freedom is not absolute. Article 19(2) permits the State to impose restrictions through law, provided they are reasonable and based only on the grounds specified in the Constitution.

Permissible grounds under Article 19(2)

A law may impose reasonable restrictions on speech only on the following eight constitutional grounds:

• The sovereignty and integrity of India protects the nation's territorial and political unity.
• The security of the State covers serious threats to the State, rather than ordinary breaches of peace.
• Friendly relations with foreign States permits restrictions protecting India's relations with other countries.
• Public order concerns public peace, safety and tranquillity.
• Decency or morality permits regulation according to constitutionally permissible standards of public decency and morality.
• Contempt of court protects the authority and proper administration of justice.
• Defamation protects a person's reputation against unlawful injury through expression.
• Incitement to an offence covers expression that encourages the commission of an offence.

Conditions governing restrictions

The restriction must be imposed by law, must fall within an enumerated ground and must be reasonable. Its validity is open to judicial review.

• There must be a sufficiently close connection between the restricted expression and the harm sought to be prevented.
• A restriction cannot be arbitrary, excessive or broader than required to protect the stated interest.
• Article 19(2) permits restriction of the right; it does not authorize the State to extinguish the freedom itself.

Constitutional development

• The Constitution (First Amendment) Act, 1951 recast Article 19(2) and added grounds including public order, friendly relations with foreign States and incitement to an offence.
• The Constitution (Sixteenth Amendment) Act, 1963 added the sovereignty and integrity of India as a ground.

How UPSC asks this