Police Closure Report

A police closure report is the police conclusion that an investigation does not provide sufficient grounds to send an accused for trial. It is commonly submitted through the final police report contemplated by Section 193 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, but the police opinion does not bind the Magistrate.

Nature of judicial scrutiny

The Magistrate must independently examine the closure report and the statements, documents and other investigation material forwarded with it. The decision is a judicial determination, not a routine endorsement of the investigating officer's conclusion.

• The Magistrate considers whether the material discloses an offence and provides sufficient ground for proceeding.
• The Magistrate cannot compel the police to file a charge sheet merely because the closure conclusion appears incorrect.

Courses open to the Magistrate

After applying judicial mind, the Magistrate may choose among legally recognised courses.

• The Magistrate may accept the closure report and terminate the proceedings.
• The Magistrate may disagree with the police and take cognizance under Section 210(1)(b) of the BNSS if the police material itself discloses an offence.
• The Magistrate may direct further investigation where the investigation is incomplete or requires additional inquiry.
• A protest petition may be treated as a complaint and processed under the statutory complaint procedure if its contents justify that course.

Procedural safeguards

In Bhagwant Singh v Commissioner of Police (1985), the Supreme Court held that the informant must receive notice and an opportunity of hearing before the Magistrate accepts a closure report and drops the proceedings. The resulting order should reflect independent application of mind and reasons.

• The informant may challenge the police conclusion through a protest petition.
• The proposed accused ordinarily has no right to participate at the pre-cognizance stage merely because the police recommended closure.

How UPSC asks this